|
a) Filing a special tax-lawsuit at the Costa Rican Court of Claims
as a legal remedy against the Fiscal Administrative Court's decision
In terms of decision, the Fiscal Administrative Court issues two
rulings: either it affirms the appellant's motion; thus, revoking
the Resolución Determinativa, or it denies the motion; which
provides the legal grounds for bringing an action. The appeal then
turns into a special lawsuit called special tax contentious-administrative
process (proceso contencioso administrativo especial tributario)
and it must be filed at the Costa Rican Court of Claims in the first
intance within 30 days after the Fiscal Court's decision has been
served to the party. The appeal is very simple in terms of content.
This is because in another stage of the process, the appellant is
summoned to state all his arguments in depth.
b) Defense from lawsuits
brought by the State against the taxpayer
Upon revocation or anullment of
the Notice of Charges (Traslado de Cargos) or the Resolución
Determinativa by the Fiscal Administrative Court, the State may
bring an action against the taxpayer. The objective is to claim
for a reversal of the administrative decision in judicial grounds;
therefore, it is also considered an appeal. As in the previous case,
the lawsuit must be filed at the Court of Claims within 30 days
of the Fiscal Court's service. This special action is technically
called proceso contencioso administrativo de lesividad, and it is
the taxpayer's responsibility to defend him/herself against the
State's lawsuit.
c) Furnish of the evidence
In both of the special judicial
actions mentioned before, the parties must attend a hearing in which
the evidence is furnished. The procedure must follow the guidelines
set in the Código de Normas y Procedimientos Tributarios,
in the Ley Reguladora de la Jurisdicción Contencioso Administrativa
and also the procedures of the Código Procesal Civil (all
of them refering to Tax legislation and procedures Code, the jurisdiction
under the administrative law legislation and the Civil Procedures
Code).
d) Appeal of the lower court's
decision
In the judicial action of the State
against the taxpayer (proceso contencioso administrativo de lesividad),
if the Court of Claims of the first instance rules against the taxpayer,
he/she must motion to the Court of Appeals.
e) Appeal to the Court of
last resort
Decisions of the Court of Appeals
in the both processes described above may be subject to an appeal
of last resort. This remedy may be used by the defendant provided
the estimation of the lawsuit exceeds a certain amount of money
and that there are enough merits to prove an error of law or breach
of some procedural right. The appeal is filed before the First Court
of Last Resort of the Supreme Court.
|